How to Remove a Single Piece of Hardwood Flooring.

O.K., so you have tongue and groove hardwood floors and you need to remove one piece.  How do you do it?  Like this …

Karen Bertelsen lifting piece of tongue and groove hardwood.

Please enjoy the strained, pretend blog smile I use on the outside when I’m a home renovation mess on the inside.

The reasons for needing to pull up a single piece of tongue and groove flooring are varied. You might want to see what the floor underneath is like.  Your cat may have peed on it and you want to replace a section without wrecking all the floor around it.  Or maybe,  just maybe, you do it for no reason at all, other than your undiagnosed home renovating mental illness known as You Might as Well Trychosis.

 

Finishing nail showing through crack in hardwood flooring.

I’m not sure if you know this or not but I’m in the midst of a design decision.  Whether to rip up my old floors to go down to the older floors, or whether to just let everything be. This is where Trychosis gets me in trouble every time.

My floor refinisher pulled up a small piece of my hardwood oak flooring while he was here assessing what my flooring options were.  He cut out a small portion of my floor in such a way that if I wanted to put the piece back no one would ever EVER know it had been removed.

I wanted to try.

How to Lift a Floor Board

  1. Pick the board you want to remove.  The shorter the board, the easier it will be to lift.
  2. Slowly run a sharp box cutter along the cracks on either side of the board.
  3. Continue cutting with the box cutter getting progressively deeper into the tongue underneath.
  4. When you feel no resistance you’re through the tongue.
  5. Gently lift the board, using a pry bar if needed.

Countersinking nail in hardwood.

So I did. And now I’ll show you how to do it in case you want to try it.  Due to your Trychosis.

The reason I couldn’t lift up a piece of this hardwood flooring easily is because of how tightly it is laid down.  If the floor has spaces in between the boards you can get a saw in there to cut between the boards.  Not so when it’s so tight.

The first thing I had to do was knock down a couple of finishing nails that were sticking up. If you have any any nail sticking up just using a nail punch and a hammer to hammer it down.  If you do any DIY and you don’t have a nail punch I’m gonna let you know right now your disorder isn’t nearly as bad as  you think.  Also you should buy a nail punch.

Cutting between crack in tongue and groove  hardwood with boxcutter.

Your second step to removing a single piece of tongue and groove hardwood is to run a box cutter down the seam between two boards.  Just gently pull it through.  Keep doing that, going deeper and deeper until you can feel you’ve cut through the entire tongue of the hardwood.

 

Cutting through oak tongue and groove strip flooring crack to remove single piece.

This is not a fast process.  It probably took me 45 minutes to cut through both sides of one 2′ board.  You have to go carefully so you don’t cut yourself or slip and cut the hardwood.

Karen Bertelsen running boxcutter along crack of tongue and groove flooring to remove single piece.

The sharper your boxcutter, the easier this will be.

TIP:

Don’t pull towards any part of your body. Make sure your hands, legs and feet are out of the way in case you slip.

Gently coaxing piece of oak tongue and groove up with claw hammer.

Once you’ve cut through the tongue there may still be nails holding the strip down. Gently pry it up with a prybar or hammer.

Lifting single piece of cut out flooring to reveal pine underneath.

Once it gives loose pull your board out.

This technique cuts through both tongues on either side of the board you removed.

You can now take a moment to stare at whatever is underneath the floor you removed.  If your lucky it will be money. You’ll be staring down at gobs and gobs of money.  Or a hidden Renaissance painting.  Me? I was staring down at another floor.

Once you’ve satisfied your Trychosis, simply wipe the sawdust and shavings away and place the board back down.  If it’s going down for good, just drizzle the back with some wood glue before you put the wood back in place.

You can’t tell at all that one of those floorboards was removed and put back down.

If your floors are up against built in cabinets or baseboards use a multisaw to cut through the end of the board.

The reason you wouldn’t use this to cut through the sides of the flooring also is because even though the cut it makes is very thin, it’s still thicker than the seams between the boards.  In other words, if you put the flooring back, the cuts wouldn’t be invisible like they are if you use a boxcutter.

Again, if you’re a DIYer and you don’t own one of these tools you really should. Mine is the Dremel Multi-Max, but there are a few different makes of them.

So now that I’ve seen another section of the pine flooring  under my dining room floor am I closer to making a decision about whether to pull the floors up?

Yes.  Yes I am.

 

→Follow me on Instagram where I often make a fool of myself←

 

Cat pee on your hardwood?  One board mangled after an axe throwing party mishap?  Here's how to lift a single board from your tongue and groove flooring without wrecking the board or any of the boards around it.

47 Comments

  1. Tina says:

    You pull up flooring in a ruffled, lavender shirt and high heeled boots and clean jeans? That’s why I can’t do my own floors! I don’t own the right clothes!

  2. The suspense is killing me.

    I hope you will tell us what kind of wood that old floor is and other Interesting Details.

    And: NAIL PUNCH? So many things I don’t know exist and then I WANT THEM.

  3. Grammy says:

    I have three nail punches in different sizes. That’s because my DIY illness is much older than yours (I think it’s even older than you). I may have only used one of them, but I don’t remember. I’m fine with that. I hope you decide soon what you’re going to do about your floors — I’m not going to pull mine up, so I want to watch you do it.

    • Sandi Remedios says:

      Nail punches come in sets of three. The only reason to own one nail punch is because you lost the other two. Either in a wall, or down a heat vent, or the dog took it outside to bury it.

  4. Cool. There is an even better tool for getting rid of those nails, called straight pin punches. A ‘regular’ nail punch gets wider the deeper you go (fine for your thin flooring, but on thicker stuff…) but a straight one doesn’t. Like these…. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Dasco-Pro-Pin-Punch-Set-6-Piece-22/100155966

    The most difficult part is levering the piece out without damaging the sides. The wider the ‘blade’ on the chosen implement the better. I like a 3″ paint scraper.

    Looking forward to seeing what you run with…

  5. whitequeen96 says:

    I vote NOOOOO – DON’T DO IT! The pine floor underneath looks in bad shape, and your oak floor is lovely! Who knows what problems you’ll uncover? Sometimes, enough is enough!

    • Karen says:

      Looks in bad shape, lol? It’s hard to tell I guess if you don’t have an understanding of floors, but it’s in perfect shape. It just needs to be sanded. 🙂 ~ karen!

  6. Virginia Riegel says:

    LOL, *of course* old floor uniformity and lots of work to the final reveal of this buried treasure is the answer!

    Greetings from another serial DIYer. Lots of laughs in your posts. Thanks for the inspiration and motivation!

  7. Heather says:

    I’d heard of trichosis but never trychosis. Thanks for introducing me to a new word. It’s so apt for so many 21st century folks. (Like the cliff-hanger at the end of the blog post: Will Karen rip up the rest of the floor boards? Or not?…)

  8. Mary W says:

    Of course you will get to the bottom – it’s part of owning an old home with charm. The real question is will it be done by Thanksgiving? or even Christmas? I think the guy that you called and exposed you to this conundrum will be part of your Christmas present to yourself. I can’t wait to see results – but surely not as much as you can’t wait. Happy DIY’ing. Tell your Mom hello from an old admirer. It makes me smile to think of her videoing you redoing your kitchen. She is another older original with lots of charm.

  9. Bruce says:

    That old pine floor would look amazing… as i’m into more of the rustic style. Not to mention, “it came with the house”! 🙂

  10. Teresa@teresachandler says:

    eek, Karen. Your friendly proofreader is here because I know you’ll want to fix this: “If your lucky it will be money.”

    I do have an incurable case of Trycosis. I am so relieved to finally have been properly diagnosed.

    I so want this to be in the new Merriam Webster dictionary next time they add new words.
    Trycosis aka Bertelsen Syndrome

  11. Christine says:

    Totally off topic.Aberfoyle had some leftover(?) Christie stuff for way lower prices.Not as much quality but still great stuff.Unfortuneatly the french fry line was way too long.

    • Jan in Waterdown says:

      Didn’t go to Christie this time but went to Aberfoyle and was wondering about the comparative prices. Maybe the vendors pay less there for a stall? Maybe a different target market, less trendy/hipster? I did lust after some carpets and a plaid blanket and a tamarack twig goose but bought a sausage……

  12. linda in Illinois says:

    my guess … you’ll go all the way down to the beginning of time on those floors because you can and because you don’t do things in halfsies. All or none. Go for it Karen !! i’ll support your decision.

  13. linda in Illinois says:

    Another comment/question from me.. why do you have a pair of binoculars next to you. ????

  14. Marc says:

    I hope I never catch that trychosis disease, I’ll be calling my doctor for the preemptive drugs!

  15. Go for it! You will LOVE the pine floor!

    We’re behind you!!!

    Far, far behind you, looking on with interest.

  16. Cathy R says:

    You are so pulling up your floors. I knew it a month ago.

  17. Heather Sykora says:

    What a clever idea to allow some reconnaissance!!

  18. Susan Schneider says:

    I am betting you will go down to the pine. Because you can. I think it’ll be awesome.

  19. Renee Ryz says:

    Will there be a way to donate or re-use the beautiful oak planks that you will undoubtedly be tearing up? That is what always gets me during a rehab – how can this or that still be used or donated. Can’t wait to see it, we all know you are ripping them up.

  20. Accidents happens and this is something really useful to know how to DIY. Great post.

  21. Roz-Lyn says:

    Is pine the cheapest of all timber flooring / here in Australia it is.

  22. Sandi Remedios says:

    On the Janka hardness test, pine is one of the softest woods. Settlers used pine because it was cheap and plentiful, but not durable.
    You should get you some Osage Orange wood, settlers used to use that for hedging. It’s tough and cool.
    I would take it back to the pine and then put something else over it, but not an endangered wood. Have you looked at end cut flooring? It is amazing!

    • Karen says:

      Old pine is durable and hard. Pine that was laid 150 years ago would have been cut from trees that were hundreds of years old and were slow growth trees. You can recognize it because the rings on it are incredibly close together (which is what gives it strength), as opposed to the pine we purchase now from box stores. ~ karen!

  23. Shawna says:

    I would totally take the flooring off and go down to the older foooring. It looks like it would have even more character than what you have now:) Plus you never know, you might just find gobs of money!
    Teehee

  24. Robert Borland says:

    I didn’t get the part on the replacement piece, are you also cutting the tonge off the new replacement? There not inter locked if so, pine expanse and contracts, sure its a tight fit installing the new piece,and there is always gonna be movement, this demo only cover end pieces, rookie suspect

    • Karen says:

      This was just lifting a single board. To see what kind of flooring is underneath for instance. Yes, if you were going to replace with a new piece of hardwood you would simply cut off the tongue portion of the board and set it down. I’m not sure what you’re referring to with “rookie suspect.” ~ karen!

  25. Connie says:

    In my 140 year old house I ripped up the horrible flooring to expose the old pine, had it refinished, and it looked beautiful – for a short time. The first couple parties left me wishing I had gone over it with new flooring. It would have cost about the same. High heels, cocktails and dancing make a mess of pine, even the really old stuff! A few use ago we put new bamboo flooring (which doesn’t look at all like bamboo, it’s lovely) in the cottage and notwithstanding the dogs, kids, sand, toys, boots, etc., it is still pristine!

    • Karen says:

      All of the floors in my house are antique pine (other than the ones I hadn’t yet exposed) and none of those floors are terribly damaged. There’s the odd gauge where I’ve dragged 500 lb buffets across it, lol, but that isn’t something that worries me. I also use my butcher block counter mark and don’t care that it has gouges and cuts in it. ~ karen!

    • Karen says:

      (oop!) Also a big factor in how well your floor will stand up is always what kind of finish you’ve put on it. I’ve purchased a professional quality, extra hard matte finish. ~ karen!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Optionally add an image (JPEG only)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Art of Doing Stuff