Garden Tool Handle Repair

2 Shares

This week I replaced a broken tool handle with... the same broken tool handle. It was for my stirrup hoe, and I would now like to know why this has never occurred to me before. Garden tool handle repair is surprisingly simple—especially when you skip the math and let desperation take over.

An old wood tool handle, planed by hand with shavings and shuffle hoe head underneath. — After hand planing an old shovel handle it's ready to fit into its new home of a Hula Hoe.

I have no fewer than four tools that slice weeds off at soil level, because I take personal satisfaction in dandelion decapitation. My stirrup hoe (Hula Hoe, scuffle hoe ... all the same thing) was one of my 4 favourites—until it snapped in half and became slightly less useful.

The handle wasn’t rotted. That’s the key detail here. It was solid. A pretty clean break. The kind of thing you look at and think, Oh. You still have potential. You just failed spectacularly.

Basement Descent & Other Risks

I ran down to the basement with the broken hoe.

And by ran I mean descended carefully down my 1840s death stairs into a space built by someone who believed in the structural integrity of loosely stacked rocks. If I'm being honest, they're less stairs than ladder. A sladder.

The only thing that truly runs down them are centipedes.

I’ve replaced wood handles before, but for whatever reason, it never occurred to me to reuse one until now. Here’s the full shovel handle replacement process if you're doing that instead.

Once down in the basement, I realized I couldn’t just saw the broken end flat and call it a day. The Hula Hoe head needed a tapered fit. Like a wedge. Something with shape. Precision. Possibly geometry.

I couldn't be bothered to dig out my belt sander so I grabbed my little 6" handheld planer.

How to Reuse a Garden Tool Handle (Step-by-Step)

It's surprisingly fast and easy. This isn’t a restoration. It’s a strategic act of impatience.

Broken shovel handle with jagged and discoloured end, a red hand planer, yardstick and wood shavings below. — Pre cutting the end off.

Step 1: Cut the broken tool handle down to solid wood.
Step 2: Use a hand planer to slowly shave it into a tapered shape.
Step 3: Check the fit often. If it’s tight, you’re doing it right.

A green gloved hand holds a red hand planer as it shaves off the end of a wood shovel handle to taper it.

TIP: Use a rubber palmed glove to hold the planer so you have a really good grip. It makes the job easier.

Would you like to save this stuff?

We'll email you this post, so you can refer to it later.

Step 4: Once shaped, test it in the socket. It should be tight.
Step 5: Tap it into place with a mallet or hammer to set the handle.

A stirrup hoe being fit for a new hand planed handle.

Setting a hula hoe head onto a new handle using a hammer.

Step 6: If you don’t have a bolt, use a nail and hammer it through the hole(s) to secure the head. I had an especially long nail so I just hammered the head over for now so I don't impale myself while using the hoe. I'll get a proper bolt eventually to replace it with.

HAHAHAHAHA.

I will never do that.

A nail protrudes out and is bent back, from a scuffle hoe.

That’s it. Handle restored. Tool functional. Brain satisfied.

The Planing

I didn’t measure anything. There was no radius. No circumference. No math. Just a hand tool and a desperate need to weed before dark.

I shaved one side, spun it, shaved another. Stopped to test the fit. Shaved again. The whole thing took maybe ten minutes and required exactly zero brainpower.

Which is probably why it felt so meditative.

And that’s it. The stirrup hoe is back in action. While I was looking up how much new stirrup hoes go for I found something that looks brilliant, but might be garbage. I don't know. I may have to buy one.

It's a shuffle hoe like mine, but it has a steel handle. A STEEL HANDLE THAT WILL NEVER ROT. But maybe it'll rust?

Anyhow, here's the link to the steel handled hoe if you want to have a look and then please report back to me. It's only $19.

This is a fast fix. An I can't be bothered to do a single thing more than this fix. An I want to weed immediately and I'm gonna do what I have to do to make that happen fix.

This isn't a retired person fix. This isn't a craftsman, precision shave, I subscribe to Popular Woodworking fix.

Because if it was that kind of a fix, it still wouldn't be done.