How to Germinate Carrots

The fella’s favourite birthday cake is carrot cake with a cream cheese icing.  It’s what his mother used to make him.

This year my plan was to grow all the carrots I needed to make the cake for his birthday which is in January.  An ambitious plan that has gone horribly, horribly wrong.

Why?

Carrots are a bitch to germinate.

Last year I planted carrots in early April.  Their germination was sporadic at best.  A clump would grow and then nothing else would. Then a month later a few more would sprout.  I had a decent carrot harvest but nothing like what I’d planted.

Carrots like 2 things to germinate.  Darkness and moisture.  Like mould. Or a yeast infection.   If they don’t have either of these things for even a day, their germination rate can drop by 50%.

Now, I knew this little fact going into my planting schedule this year so I armed myself with a fool proof plan.  Problem is, that fool proof plan, hadn’t seen this fool. I tried a technique I’d seen on the Internet.  It involves gluing each and every carrot seed onto a piece of paper towel, than placing that towel of glued seeds onto your garden soil and covering it with a very thin layering of compost.

You then water the paper towels and soil, cover them with a board to keep them dark and VOILA … in 7-14 days you  have nothing.  At all.  Oh wait.  No, no, I see one. There’s a single little set of carrot leaves.  After 20 days.

So yesterday I set about trying to figure this out for reals.  I hate the stupid Internet because it really is a big, fat LIAR but sometimes listening to what might be a lie, is your only hope in hell of getting something done.

The one thing that seemed to make a lot of sense was getting your carrot seeds to germinate PRIOR to planting them.  I sussed out a few methods and decided on this one.

You need squares of cardboard, carrot seeds, and paper towels.

DSC 0802

 

Place a very damp paper towel on a piece of cardboard (or anything else sturdy).

DSC 0814

 

Place your carrot seeds 2 inches apart across the whole paper towel until it’s covered.  You’ll plant about 20-25 seeds per paper towel.  Since I plant a lot of carrot varieties, I label each board to know what’s what.

DSC 0816

DSC 0819 B

 

 

Cover with another wet paper towel.

DSC 0820

 

 

Continue doing this with all of your seeds.

DSC 0824

 

 

Stack the boards up and place the entire stack in a plastic bag and put it in a dark area.

DSC 0836

 

Then wait.

I am currently in the waiting phase.  In 7 – 10 days you can check to see if anything’s going on in there.

As soon as the seeds have germinated and have a tiny root on them you can take the piece of cardboard and paper towel outside. Carefully  slip the paper towel off of the cardboard and onto your (very well dug)  garden soil.  Cover with a 1/4 or less of compost or vermiculite.

Bake at 375° for 45 minutes, or until toothpick comes out clean.

 

update: It is now 12:45 a.m.  I just got out of bed to check on my carrot seeds.  Like any normal person would.  THEY HAVE SPROUTED.  In 7 days my carrot seeds have sprouted.  Which is unheard of in the carrot world.  It’s a little carrot miracle.  Lord only knows what else is possible if I put my mind and the Internet lies to work.  

I will be planting the carrots outside tomorrow.  Behold the seeds of hope.

There may be a birthday cake being served, yet.

 

carrot-sprout

 

 


103 Comments

  1. Becky says:

    I will be interested to see how this works.. carrots are my nemesis in the garden.

    Its just easier, and less frustrating, to just buy a bag…. they don’t taste anything like a homegrown carrot, but I sacrifice taste for lower blood pressure.

    • RCA says:

      So how did it turn out in the end? I am considering giving it a try but if the yield was marginal, I don’t want to go to the trouble.

      I blame some of my carrot problems on the birds who I believe may eat the seedlings but I have that solved by putting various barriers in their way so they can’t get to the seedlings.

      • Karen says:

        Hi RCA. I’ve tried a few things over the years and this really does work. You don’t get 100% success rate but more than just planting each individual seed in the soil and walking away. HOWEVER I’ve had the absolute best success with slightly overseeding into damp soil (you don’t have to go crazy overboard with the overseeding) and covering with a board for around a week. Keep lifting the board every day or so to check for germination. Once you see several of the seeds have germinated and are sending up tiny shoots, remove the board. They carrot seeds thrive in the damp, darkness under the boards. ~ karen!

        • Kirk says:

          Trying something new this year. I am reusing an old fridge and kept the freezer door just to cover the top where I will be planting carrots just to hold in the moisture and keep it dark, will let yall know how it works out.

  2. gloria says:

    I suspect you would not want to be laying the paper towel with its spriglets onto the ground on a windy day? Also, almost every seed i plant has to be covered with flexible plastic mesh (the kind used to keep leaves out of rain gutters) or the chipmunks will dig them up and eat them. When the plants begin to break through the soil, I can remove the mesh. I guess I’d have to do the same with this carrot method. Or it would be like providing Chip and Dale with a paper towel to wipe their mouths after they eat my seeds.

  3. Jean in BC says:

    I’ll have to try this! I grew carrots last year. They were as big as the picture on the seed envelope – 1-2″

    Your front yard garden is really inspiring. Makes me want to change out my front yard! Have you every tried those upside down planters for tomatoes or strawberries? I haven’t had much success with those – think “Charlie Brown” tomato plant lol.

  4. Yay for carrot sprouts!! I remember my one and only batch of carrots in the garden. It was a meager harvest. However, the highlight was allowing a friend’s little boy to come pick his own carrot…he managed to pick a HUGE one, and he almost tumbled over backwards when it finally popped out of the ground. He wanted to eat it right away, but his mom and I convinced him to wait until we went into the house and washed it off.

    Later his dad told me that he had caught his little boy heading out back with a store-bought bag of baby carrots. “Whatcha doing with those?” “I’m going to plant them and grow big carrots.” “Um, son, it doesn’t work that way.” Well, the dad said the little boy wouldn’t be denied, and he went out and planted that bag of baby carrots! LOL! So I didn’t get a bunch of carrots in my garden, but I got a great memory that makes me smile each time I think about it!

    Hope you get a great batch of carrots for your cake!

  5. bex says:

    O boy, I am sure going to look forward to trying this. I wonder if it’s better to get most veg seeds sprouting before planting. Waiting for spring 🙂

    • Karen says:

      Hi Bex – Most things aren’t nearly as finicky about germinating as carrots so there’s no need to do it with everything else. Just these stupid carrots! ~ karen

  6. Jennifer says:

    I never realized that different areas of the country might have different results. Carrots are easy for me (Peace country in northern Alberta) – broadcast the seeds straight from the pack, brush a little dirt (and that’s nothing special)and firm it down with my hands or the rake. Given some rain, they almost all come up. Maybe it’s the variety? I’ve only ever planted Nantes, and they taste wonderful.

    • Hannah says:

      Me too, Jennifer. I’m on the BC side of the Peace Country, and I have never, EVER had a problem germinating carrots, which you think would be weird, because it’s 1) bone dry and 2) light all day and night.

  7. Jennifer says:

    Forgot to add – I do hope this works for you; I’ll be paying attention to find out. All the best!

  8. brittany says:

    Due to lack of indoor space, I did paper towel germination for all of my veggies (except carrots, go figure) this year with great success! Transplanting into cups and moving to a makeshift greenhouse had about a 60% success rate, and I got everything into the garden this holiday Monday. As for my carrots, they went into the ground in March between the rows of lettuce and have already begun to peek out, but germination was still spotty. I think I might give your method a try next time. Thanks for the post!

  9. AndiB says:

    Speaking of internet carrot lies…have you heard the one about growing them in liter soda bottles? Just wondering if this piece of propaganda would actually work.

  10. Laura M says:

    I am going to try this! I don’t have trouble germinating carrots but my rows are always crowded…this trick will definitely give order to raised beds.

  11. And then once you get them to germinate, they’ll behave like normal plants? I’ve planted 5 sets so far, different kinds, different parts of the garden. Got 3 or 4 lousy sprouts. This is embarrassing for someone who writes a garden & food blog. They did fine the last 2 years, then this year, they suddenly refused. Glad to hear it’s not just me.
    And yes, getting up in the middle of the night to check your seeds is completely normal.

    • Karen says:

      Claire – Yes, once they germinate the hard part’s over (finger’s crossed). They need to get in the garden right away though. ~ karen!

  12. Laura Bee says:

    This is fantastic – I am just starting to get my veggies in & have three different carrot varieties. I know I would have just poked a hole & dropped them in & wondered why they didn’t grow.
    My little sister, me and five visiting kids ate a whole row of my mom’s carrots one year. NOW I understand why she was so upset. I don’t remember if I was spanked – but it was worth it if I was. They were so little & so sweet.
    p.s. The papertowel way is how I start my morning glories. I stick them in my Tupperware celery keeper. But they like a sunny window & pop out almost overnight.

    • Karen says:

      omg! That’s the other thing I can’t seem to grow! I have Morning Glory curse. I’ve finally given up on them. ~ k

      • Sera says:

        Morning glory behaves like a weed here. It crawls everywhere and now I have sprouts in my grass. I’m certain I’ll never get rid of it. As much as I love those pretty flowers, it’s not worth taking over everything!
        On the other hand, I planted carrots for the first time this year and they all seem to have germinated just fine. It must be the moldy dark climate I live in. We’ll see how they taste!

      • Shauna says:

        I’ve read that Morning Glories are poisonous for chickens – you don’t want them. Plus, once you get them growing, they never stop and they get into every crevice. My poor neighbors dilapidated garage started to have my vines coming through before we ripped them all out. It took months before we got them to stop growing and I could bring in the chickens.

  13. Candice says:

    I was surprised to see that carrots are hard to grow. Maybe it’s the variety I plant, Red Core Chantennay, but I’ve never had a problem with them sprouting after I direct sow the seeds in the soil.

  14. Emily says:

    aaawwwww Little sprouts!

  15. Holly says:

    I did this for the first time this year and got nothing. NOTHING!!!

    • Karen says:

      You did the paper towel thing? If that’s true then it’s possible the paper towels weren’t wet enough. They have to be wet enough to stay damp for a week. ~ karen!

    • Toronto Boy says:

      Holly, keep an eye on them. If the paper towel isn’t damp enough, a spray bottle comes in quite handy. A few sprays and you are back on track!

  16. Hilarious post! But I don’t know — this seems like a royal pain in the ass, just for carrots. 🙂 I direct-sowed some last week (my first time) and it’s been raining ever since, so maybe I have a chance!!

    • Karen says:

      It’s really not that big of a pain. Seems like it, but for perfect rows of instantly germinated carrots? Not bad at all! 🙂 ~ karen

  17. Su says:

    I’ve been buying the carrot seeds in a seed tape from Burpee. Just lay it into a small trench, cover and water. One less thing to stress about!

  18. karol says:

    Is it just me, or isn’t it dark and moist underground? Phew, who knew carrots were fussy.

    • Karen says:

      Karol – It’s only moist WAyyyyyyyy down in the ground. Carrots are scattered on top of the soil with only 1/8th an inch of soil or so over them. So the top of the soil dries out fast. Stupid soil ~ karen

  19. Kim says:

    Sounds like something I would do except my thing is checking incubator cause who doesn’t love new hatched chicks at 2am?

    LOVE me some carrot cake with CREAM CHEESE FROSTING! Send carrots when you have them. I’ve missed the “cool season” crops if the south has such a thing. Tomatoes look awesome though. Trade?

  20. SuzyM says:

    I’ve tried this technique with seeds that take forever to germinate like arisaema (Jack in the Pulpit) and peonies, but never thought to try carrots. Off to the seed store.

    I am also guessing that you keep both layers of paper toweling on the seeds?

    • Karen says:

      I’m actually not sure what I’m going to do about that SuzyM. I’m actually thinking I”ll get rid of the top layer of paper towel and cover them with vermiculite. ~ karen!

    • Toronto Boy says:

      SuzyM:
      If you are having problems growing peonies from seeds, try getting a cutting from a mature plant. Dip the cutting in rooting powder and place in soil, ensuring that the soil is kept moist. The first year, it will be quite short. The second year, it will grow taller. If you are lucky, it may have a flower or two. By the third year, you should have a mature plant that has lush blooms! Good luck!

  21. Ann says:

    I have had pretty good luck with using the method where you plant the seed in the ground, water and cover with a board. But never does it work perfectly. I still have the random blank patch in the row.

    And I have to keep everything covered or the chickens will denude the carrots down to soil level. And for some strange reason, carrots need those leaves to grow. Love my chickens, I love my chickens, I really do love my chickens

  22. Maria says:

    Would I use the same method for parsnips? I read the seed packet and it clearly stated that the seeds need to be kept moist to germinate them. And I thought, ‘How in the world do I stay on top of that?’ Thanks for the tip!

    • Karen says:

      Hi Maria – Yes, that’s a great idea. I grew some parsnips last year and now that I think of it, they did the same thing as the carrots. They *did* eventually germinate, but not all of them and it took a long time. ~ karen!

  23. Natalia says:

    That sounds like a lot of work but hopefully it will pay off. What helped me to get more carrots to grow was… sowing lots of them. I know this sounds obvious but if you think about that – not all of the seeds you buy in a package will germinate, some are older, some are weaker. That’s what my grandmother tought me and one doesn’t question grandma and her gardening skills! You seed quite a lot in a row and when they pop up and grow a bit you pull the weaker ones out to give more space to others. You can see it well here http://www.vegetable-garden-guide.com/growing-carrots.html Although I found this post on pinterest and one should maybe question that!
    Thank you for such an inspirational blog and regular dose of humor.

    • Karen says:

      Thanks Natalia – The reason I don’t overseed is, it’s less work to begin with but more work later. But more importantly, because I buy a lot of hard to find heirloom seeds and don’t want to waste too many of them. ~ karen!

      • Natalia says:

        That’s a good point! I’ll remember about your tips for the special heirloom seeds. Thank you for replying, you made my day 🙂

  24. Laura M says:

    Carrots are not easy for many people. This year we dug a small trench in the ground and saturated it with water so there is plenty of moisture under the seed. Sprinkle seed in. Cover it lightly and in one week we have huge success with germination.

  25. Allison says:

    I am surprised to learn that carrots are problematic. I always seed them straight into the garden at the end of May and up they come! I usually have to thin them.

    Now, of course, I’ve probably jinxed myself, and the lovely multi-coloured variety I just planted will all fail to launch.

  26. Nanette says:

    Congrats on your progress so far! I love carrot cake. One question, do you keep the paper towels moist during the waiting period or is the plastic enough to hold the moisture?

    • Karen says:

      Nanette – I had success using very damp paper towels, putting plastic wrap between each bundle and putting it all in a plastic bag. Things are *just* starting to dry out a bit after one week. ~ karen!

  27. Debbie says:

    Just wanted to say thank you.

    Thank you for motivating me to start my own garden. this weekend we are building an above ground enclosed vegetable garden – we are overrun with rabbits and I do not want it all for not.

    curious to hear how your carrots turn out.

    • Karen says:

      Thank YOU for letting me know! I always wonder what people just read about here and what they are actually inspired to do. Have fun with your garden. You’ll LOVE it. ~ karen!

    • BarBee says:

      I would love to hear how your rabbit battles go. Our weekend place has herds of them.

  28. Langela says:

    I have to say, I use the paper towel/napkin method you first mentioned, with great success. For me, it works for carrots and radishes the best. I won’t do them any other way anymore. Especially here on the windy farm. If I don’t glue those tiny seeds to a mat, they will grow everywhere!

  29. Ellen says:

    Thank you thank you thank you….. going to use gutter gards since I have a chipmunk problem also. Oh happy day!!!

  30. Leslie says:

    Thank you for this info! I can’t for the life of me get my carrots to grow. Not a single one! They’re the only veggie my son requested and I’ve been so frustrated with them. Can’t wait to try this method. Please keep us posted on how they do.

  31. Michelle says:

    This is awesome!! Just in time, too!

  32. Well I am glad you have had carrot success! All mine are good for is rabbit food!I have given up and continue my asparagus garden!

  33. pooks says:

    What the hey? I had no idea they were difficult. This explains why I have had so much trouble with them! Duh! And, thanks!

  34. RuthyJ says:

    If this actually works, I may think of trying my hand at carrots again. 0-5 carrots – after bed prep, soil amendments, seed-sowing, and faithful watering at a time when I should still be in bed – is not my cup of tea. Like Becky, I opted for lower blood pressure.

    • Karen says:

      Well Ruth, I have to say I’m very impressed with how well it’s went so far. Jamaica’s pretty hot for carrots though. That cold be part of the problem. They like to grow in cool weather. Keep trying tho! ~ karen

      • RuthyJ says:

        There are other folk around here who grow carrots successfully for the market, but they do it in the hills… but we don’t have much shade in our yard, so that might be the problem. :-/

        We may be ‘pulling up stakes’ and moving in a couple of months, so I will try again then.

  35. Leona says:

    Bake at 375, huh? lol

    I will absolutely try this next year. Thanks.

  36. Pat says:

    Never knew carrots were a problem. Although I haven’t planted any in a few years, I used to just plunk the seeds in the ground, around the May weekend, and have carrots to eat in August. We live in the Fraser Valley, outside Vancouver, B.C. Who knew….

  37. ruth says:

    My problem isn’t germination, it’s the little worms burrowing into them. I live in the Fraser Valley too, Pat. You don’t have a problem with the worms? I’ve given up because of them.

  38. Marie says:

    I just can’t get over that in May you’re starting work on a birthday cake for January! You’re amazing!

  39. Mary Kay says:

    We have tried growing carrots in the past – and had little fat 2″ carrots. So maybe I will try this method. My question is you put the paper towel in the ground with the germinated seeds on top and cover with dirt? Will the carrots grow through the paper towel?

  40. Krista Wilkinson says:

    karen, have you heard of carrot flies? saw a post on them earlier this year, they develop after you have a successful carrot planting and then they apparently wait until the next year when you plant again. I was very successful my first year and then after that I would get germination but no carrots. Apparently you have to keep changing the location in the garden to thwart the little buggers

    • Karen says:

      Krista – That’s true of most things. You’re always best to rotate where you plant things because of this. Pest and disease will pop up the next year. My carrots are in a different spot this year, although with a garden as small as mine is, you can only move things so far away from where they were before. 🙂 ~ karen

  41. Nancy Blue Moon says:

    This method seems quite easy to me..what work is it to wet some paper towels, put seeds on them cover them and put them a plastic bag..if it works (and it did) it seems a fairly easy way to get them started..I hope they do as well in the ground..

  42. Sera says:

    Oh, and when it comes time to make carrot cake, I posted the best carrot cake recipe ever on my blog. It has mascarpone lime frosting! I can attest that my mom then promptly made cupcakes out of the recipe and my step-dad hasn’t stopped bugging her to make more.

  43. Molly says:

    I am sitting here counting my carrot blessings because I’ve never had trouble getting them to sprout. I grow my carrots in a big half wine barrel–I fill it with loose, rich soil, put the seed down, cover it loosely with a bit more soil and then cover the barrel with mesh until they are big enough to withstand critters who try to bury their stash. They need very gentle water twice a day until the seeds are established.

  44. Barbie says:

    …..I am SO behind on my carrots …. amongst other things in the garden. I want to try this! Thanks Karen, your timing is perfect.

  45. Shauna says:

    I love that you use a tape measure! I’m such a haphazard gardener, planting seeds all willy nilly. I guess I’m lucky to live where I do because you can be a lazy gardener and still get food here. We even have two rogue tomato plants that sprouted this year from the tomatoes I used to throw on the ground for the chickens. I’ve had to jerry rig hardware wire around them to keep the chickens from eating them, but they’re huge now and I’m just waiting for some maters;)

  46. allyson says:

    You know what’s weird? We had a brutally bad carrot crop last year – a few tiny little things (that’s not the weird part). This spring, when hubby went out to prep the gardens for the season, he found a carrot, about 2″ long growing in the cold, just finished winter garden. Lovely fresh green top, orange flesh. Bizarre.

    • Karen says:

      Allyson – I found a couple of carrots this spring too. It’s actually the best way to store them for the winter. Just leave them in the ground! They don’t rot, don’t go soft and are perfect. If I have enough this year for saving that’s what I’m going to do. ~ karen!

  47. Erin says:

    Thanks for the great post! I have difficulty with carrots as well. I usually end up sowing a row every week in the hopes that I will remember to water or get lucky with rainy weather. I am definitely going to try this!

    I usually leave my carrots in the ground until the “January thaw” – they really get sweet in the cold. Just cover them with mulch to keep the ground from freezing.

    I had two rows of carrots overwinter under floating row cover this winter. I seeded them in August and they just didn’t get big enough to pull, so we left them. I’m not sure if they’ll size up or just shoot a flower stalk when it warms up. Life’s an experiment.

  48. Shelly says:

    Gees…I would never have guessed, by the millions of tiny frilly carrot tops that I had to weed around every summer in my father’s garden, that carrots were so darn finicky. Nothing like sitting in the dirt pulling tiny blades of weeds when you’d rather be outside doing ANYTHING else. Of course, now, I would LOVE to be weeding carrots rather than cleaning toilets and some of the other really crappy jobs that moms/wives have to do…

  49. Sara says:

    Thank god it’s not just me and my crappy clay soil or my inconsistent watering or whatever cause of the week! I haven’t had luck with my carrots either and was about to give up on them. I’ll have to try out this method too. Thank you!

  50. Jennifer says:

    Dear Karen: I planted Cubit’s (per your recommendation because you’re my hero) Colorful Carrot Mix seeds this year about the first or second week of May (in Michigan). I made a little trench, mixed the seeds with a bit of sand, and carefully sprinkled the seed/sand mixture in my trench. I then covered with dirt about 1/4 inch deep and a very, little bit of straw on top. I watered daily, and those little babies popped right up. No baking or glue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Optionally add an image (JPEG only)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Art of Doing Stuff