Maple Butter, Maple Spread, Maple Cream, whatever you want to call it, now that you know it exists you’re doomed. IT’S deadly DELICIOUS and it only takes one ingredient. Maple syrup.
I need you to shut up and listen for once. You need to make this right now. Right, right now. People overuse the word miracle all the time because they have no respect for the true meaning of it. If they can fit in their pants after Christmas they say it’s a miracle. That’s not a miracle, that’s Spandex.
THIS however, is a bona fide, sent from the heavens, sweet baby Jesus/Buddha/Vishnu/the One miracle.
Maple cream. Otherwise known as maple butter or maple spread. I’ll be using the terms interchangeably in this post ’cause they’re all the same thing.
I may have mentioned I make maple syrup. Maybe. So I’ve been trying to figure out a few different ways to use it beyond the standard drinking it through a hose.
Enter Maple Cream.
What is maple cream? It’s maple syrup that’s been transformed (miraculously) into a creamy, spreadable, butter-like consistency through a process of crystallization.
It’s meant to be spread on English muffins, or toast or even … on a grilled cheese with bacon and green apples.
I prefer to eat the maple butter by just taping the jar to my head and licking my way to the bottom like an anteater.
So you want to make some?
Like all delicious things it’s kind of complicated. Here’s what you need to do. Pay close attention to the following instructions:
Boil maple syrup … then stir it.
Sorry – that’s not the complicated part – the complicated part is figuring out ways to trick yourself into not eating it until you’re sick. So far, I’ve found eating it until I’m *almost* sick isn’t a guarantee that I won’t eat a little bit more until I’m sick.
Let’s do this.
How to Make Maple Cream.
What You Need
Wooden spoon
Icecubes
Maple Syrup
Bowl
2 pots
Thermometer
- Pour 3 cups of light to medium maple syrup into a pot.
Do it with flair.
2. Boil over medium/low heat WITHOUT STIRRING until the syrup reaches 235 F.
3. Immediately pour syrup into a pot set in an ice bath. Let stand WITHOUT STIRRING until the syrup cools to 100 F. (this will take around 10 minutes)
Please enjoy this Little House on the Prairie moment … I didn’t have enough ice for an ice bath so I went outside and pulled some frozen sap out of my sap buckets to use as ice.
4. Once the syrup has lowered in temperature to 100 F., remove the pot from the ice bath and start stirring.
Don’t stir like a crazy person, you don’t want to beat air into it. You just want to stir it. You will be stirring for a long time. Like, half an hour. I focused on watching television to get my mind off of my sore arm.
Eventually the syrup will start to lighten (after about 15 minutes of stirring) and then you have to keep stirring. Once it gets to be this very light colour, you don’t have long to go.
5. Continue to stir the syrup until it goes from shiny to dull and holds its shape as you run the spoon through it. This means it’s set up, the crystallization process is complete and you can STOP STIRRING!
6. Immediately pour it into your containers before it sets up too much to pour.
You now have maple cream which you stirred by hand which makes you a badass.
It’s now that I let you know you can also use a stand mixer to do this. But then you won’t be a badass with maple cream you’ll just be some schmo with maple cream. The choice is yours.
To do it with a stand mixer, instead of stirring it by hand use the stand mixer set to “stir”, or “low” with the paddle attachment. Whichever your stand mixer has as the lowest setting. Don’t forget to scrape down the sides.
Maple Cream will last for 6 months in the refrigerator. Which is a handy little tip in case you take a blow to the head and forget you own delicious Maple Cream. (There would be no other explanation for not eating it all in a week.)
The difference in these two forms of maple syrup is amazing. It is the exact same thing, just the structure of it has changed through the heating and then stirring of it to achieve crystallization.
The crystals are so small your tongue can’t detect them.
Every person I’ve had taste this has had the same reaction. Their eyes roll into the back of their heads.
Traditional Maple Cream
Ingredients
- 3 cups Maple Syrup Light - Medium
Instructions
- Bring the Maple Syrup to a boil in a pot over medium/low heat. Boil until it reaches 235 degrees F. without stirring then remove from heat immediately. This will take around 15 minutes.
- While the syrup is boiling get an ice bath ready with a pot set in a bowl of ice.
- As soon as it has reached 235 degrees F, pour the boiled syrup into the pot set in the ice bath. Leave it until it the syrup drops in temperature to 100 degrees F. Don't disturb it at all while it rests.
- Once at 100 degrees F. remove the pot from the ice bath and start stirring. Don't stir vigorously ... you don't want to beat air into the syrup ... just stir it.
- Keep stirring. The syrup will start to lighten. Keep stirring. After about 30 minutes of stirring the syrup will be very light and resemble tahini but still be glossy with the consistency of cream. KEEP STIRRING.
- The syrup will now finish crystallizing, set up and be come duller. Once your spoon starts to leave paths in the syrup you can stop stirring.
- Pour the Maple Cream into your jars right away before it becomes to difficult to pour.
Notes
Nutrition
If you’re wondering about that whole grilled cheese thing I mentioned at the beginning, this is the sandwich I’m thinking of trying it on. I realize maple syrup on a grilled cheese sandwich might sound gross, but it’s not. It’s a miracle.
→Follow me on Instagram where I often make a fool of myself←
I thought there was something wrong with me until I just read your post!!
Your description of eating and not stopping , it is so hilariously true!
Bought from farmers market and just tasted it right now . From the jar.
Had to find out how to make more.
Thank you!
It. Is. SO. Good! ~ karen!
I tried this recipe with two different brands of maple syrup. One brand worked wonderfully; the other got so hard and tacky, I could not even stir it after the ice bath. What could be the difference? Is it possible that different maple syrups can cause a different reaction? If so, have any ideas as to what the difference could be? I used the first maple syrup twice and it worked well. I used the second maple syrup twice — once using 2 cups because I needed a larger quantity and once using 1 cup because, after the first attempt, I was scared to make more. The time I used 2 cups I could at least move the spatula up and down in the maple “stickiness”. In the batch with 1 cup, it turned into a rock-solid block of maple after the ice bath — no stirring was possible. Has anyone had this reaction?
Hi Ohio. If you did every single thing exactly the same (right temps, no stirring etc.) the only thing I can think is that the other brand of syrup you used was dark syrup. For some reason (I can’t remember why, lol) you can’t use dark syrup. Only light or medium. ~ karen!
I‘m a sucker for anything containing maple sirup. Have you ever tried Maple cotton candy? TO DIE FOR!!! Maple cream has been haunting me for over 20 years and then, thanks to Pinterest , I‘ve discovered I can make it myself! Unfortunately, it wasn‘t as easy as that. None of the blogs I‘ve read mentioned using light Maple Sirup. Until researching what I could have done wrong I stumbled upon you telling me to use light to Medium! I‘m crying here because I have a whole gallon of dark Amber and the stuff is Not easy to come by in Germany. Ok, tough luck, no Maple cream for me. But now I need some Ideas what to do with my thickened Sirup. I hope you, or some of the other readers can help an fellow Addict. 😅
Maple Fudge, use in place of sugar for chocolate chip cookies, maple milkshakes
Haven’t tried the recipe yet, BUT – my husband has talked about maple cream for the 46 years we’ve been married and I had no idea what it really was until very recently when I got to taste it for the first time. I had been getting him the maple candy that is very granulated- just not the same. I am so glad to have this recipe and I think I will surprise him with some at Christmas! Thank you so much!!!
Mine hardened after I put in in the jar. Did I not stir it enough, or too much?
I think it sounds more like you had improper temperature readings and boiled it too long. But not being there it’s hard to tell. That would be my guess though. ~ karen!
My first batch hardened so I couldn’t even stir it. That batch I heated to 235 degrees. My second batch I heated to 225 which would do anything when I stirred it for 30 minutes. I put it back in my clean kettle and heated to 230 degrees and followed her same process and it worked great. 🤷🏼♀️
OK….time out…have mercy…..first Cadbury Easter Creme Eggs now Maple Cream….when do you post a blog on how to exercise off the calories you dumped on our oversized kiesters?
There is no way I would ever be able to put it in pretty jars. I would anteater my way to the bottom of the pot, licking through the copper to get every last drop!
Sorry, Gurl. I couldn’t resist… hope you love it.
Anteater licking out the box of maple cream… LOL
I once bought a jar of maple cream while on a school field trip to Québec. I made the mistake of trying it. And then having just a little more. And a little more and a little more and maybe just a little more again. Sometimes I had my fingers in there without even realizing I was doing it, like I was in a maple trance. I managed to eat the entire thing before I got home – it was an 8 hour drive in a schoolbus after all. You’d think I’d never touch the stuff again but if I do break down and buy it, it doesn’t stand a chance. I may have to try this but I am actually afraid to. Plus my only (successful) candy making experience has been Horehound, as it’s so rare to find in stores and I love it as much as my mom and Grandmama do. Run that up your Prairie flagpole and see who salutes it!
Ooh, when I was a kid, whenever we went to Black Creek Pioneer Village I bought horehound, humbugs and licorice root. Pretty sure you can still get it there. If you’re ever in the area…
Oh, good tip, thanks! And it’s on the new subway line too.
I did not need to know this, Karen.
I’m late to the party and I just read this while eating, scratch that, wolfing down toast for dinner and now I wish I had some maple cream to slather on it…drool
I love that “indigenous” is the type of cuisine you have this listed under. I’ve never heard of maple cream before. Probably because I’m not indigenous to Canada (or New England). Should I move to a place where I can tap my own trees, I’ll be making this for sure!
Bah! Just go buy a bottle and make some! I’ll be having an english muffin slathered with some in about half an hour. ~ karen!
I think I can kiss my diet goodbye! Thank you for sharing this! I’m now scouring the hidden areas in the pantry for decent maple syrup to make this 😀
Oh yeah, ditch the diet for sure, lol. Make some! ~ karen
The brother of a friend of mine makes small batch specialty maple syrups. I have ordered a bottle of his syrup which has been infused with bourbon from sitting in bourbon casks. I can’t wait to try this with it!
That would be great! Maple and bourbon is a PERFECT combination. ~ karen!
I am so ok with schmo status. Gets the maple cream to my anteater tongue quicker…
When I was a kid, back in the late fifties, we’d go to grand-maman Leroux’s farm almost every other week. For breakfast she would dole out this miracle spread which my siblings and I absolutely loved, no, read adored! My parents never bought the stuff so we only ever got it at my grandmother’s. It happens that this spread was called Map-o-spread. It was a chemically produced maple spread. We LOVED it. We were kids. Later when I realized that I had been had and tasted the real thing, I swooned. I kid you not. Maple cream or butter has the power to make one swoon. So by all means stir away or buy it ready made. But as Karen wrote, stirring gives us badass status. At my age, badass is good.
I love on your recipe card the cuisine is Indigenous. As it should be….
Beautiful! The recipe and the photographs. Thanks!
I want to do this but I will have to find light syrup to buy. Do you think it would work the same with honey? I have always wondered how they make creamed honey.
I wonder if honey could be altered in a similar way?
What about maple pecan ice cream? That sounds like a miracle waiting to happen!
Totally a miracle :)
Mine was a near disaster, although I’m willing to admit that It may be operator error. And it’s possible that I started with maple syrup that was too dark. I made the mistake of leaving the room and when I came back, it had cooled too much to be stirred. Then I tried warming it by setting the bowl in hot water to get it back to 100°. But even then, it was probably too thick. I used my mixer, but it wasn’t getting lighter in color or loosening up, so then I added a tablespoon of butter to loosen it, and this resulted in it turning into something more like caramel. Delicious caramel, but too thick to spread on anything. There was no way I was going to waste it though, so I scraped it into a jar and I’m thinking it might be perfect in oatmeal. The heat of the cereal should melt it and the flavor is out of this world. If I tried it again, I would not leave the room and I would use the hand string method.
Even though I’m not a fan of maple flavour, I found this fascinating to read!! It’s incredible to think that just the simple (although tiring) act of stirring the syrup and watching the clock produces an entirely different product! How the heck do you ever know all these amazing facts, Karen?!
Looks yummy, I need to try this. Try dipping cheddar cheese in maple syrup, that’s my favorite indulgent.
I buy maple butter whenever I find it, thank goodness I don’t find it too often. I wouldn’t be able to trust myself with making my own. It would never make it into the jars.
Ohhhhhh… I knew it as maple butter. I haven’t had it in years… I’m drooling. I need this… NOW!
O.M.G. Thank you.
WECK JARS! (Sigh….i have problems).
Heading north for Easter and my uncle makes maple syrup, so there will definitely be Maple Cream in my future. Probably the Schmuck version with stand mixer. Or maybe I can con my kids into pretending they’re Laura Ingalls to do the stirring…NM, they can’t be trusted around something this delicious.
😋 I love maple syrup and I am going to try this to serve at Easter brunch.
Making maple cream, that is…
White Meadows, Fonthill, Ont. for farm fresh maple syrup…yum.
Grilled peanut butter and apple sandwich… yum. Gorilla Cheese… yum. Visiting soon a friend in North Bay and making this together… yum.
Sounds delicious Karen! I make soap and ‘stirring the pot’ is something that goes along with it, so half an hour of stirring is nothin’! I do have a question… where did you find the beautiful canning type jar that you poured the maple cream into? Would love to get some. Also love your ice cube tray. Nice find! I am of a certain age that I have memories of them from my childhood….
Hi Cindy! The tall jar is a Weck jar which you can get on Amazon. And the other squat jar is just a regular preserves jar. I got the nostalgic ice cube tray at a local kitchen store. :) ~ karen!
Thanks so much Karen… I know you are incredibly busy and I really appreciate you taking the time and effort to answer! I do have loads of the regular Mason jars but love the look of the Weck style. Will definitely look into getting some. And it’s amazing that you can find the ice cube trays at a local (‘new-age’) kitchen store! Think I will keep my eyes open for those as well.
I WILL be doing this on the weekend! Thanks for sharing :)
Theoretically, shouldn’t this work with molasses? Because….Alabama?
Do not even suggest that. I am a sorghum molasses addict, so much so that I will sneak spoonfuls of the stuff when hubby isn’t watching. He hates it and likes to laugh at my addiction. This would change everything! Sorghum molasses on a hot buttered piece of corn bread is always calling my name and molasses cream would be heaven.
A little Molasses is great in a glass of milk instead of chocolate! If you get your hands on sap right from the tree it makes delicious oatmeal. Just substitute sap for the water, and make tea with sap instead of water. I love to make flan and use maple sugar instead of white sugar in the bottom of the pan. All that sweet mapley yumminess running down the side of the flan. Mmmmmmm
Bad news; the recipe requires cream since crystallization is different in molasses. Good news; the recipe also contains rum! https://grandmasmolasses.com/recipes/molasses-whipped-cream/
Alabama would have been a perfectly valid reason if the crystallization thing didn’t come into play.
Hi Karen
What is the reason for only using light to medium syrup?
Apparently dark syrup may not set up properly Deb. ~ karen!
Hi Karen,
I love Maple syrup so much I buy a case of 12 cans just about every year to a year and a half. I always wondered how to make Maple butter and there you are with the recipe. Thank you so much Karen for sharing. I like to print and save the recipes I want to make and was just wondering why is it that the picture is not included in the print?
P.S. I love reading your blog you make me laugh!
I guess I’ll finally have to get a thermometer!
Fun fact I once kept a jar of caramel chile cream for like 3 years because I couldn’t figure out what to do with it even though I made it.
It finally filled a chocolate sable tart crust that spent another 3 months in the freezer because it was to indulgent to eat too much of it at once
Thanks, Karen. On fresh warm, fragrant homemade bread, or buttered toast, or crackers, or right off the spoon or knife, or fingers, or…….. Great timely blog and extra fine pics. Just bought my usual gallon of maple syrup a couple of days ago from a mennonite gal by the side of the road; her horse was hobbled in the woods nearby. 2018 not the best production year- not much snow cover and cold March days means sap runs slowly. However, its still running. Made maple syrup as a lad with my grandfather and his friends at the farm, in a huge cast iron cauldron, later with an old friend- spend all night in the sugar bush shack chatting and keeping the fire going; great atmosphere. Miracle. As a wise sceptic was want to say: evidence is the only reason to believe …… anything. Thanks for supplying the evidence, Karen.
I ordered 3 large bottles of pure dark maple syrup from a Vermont store. It cost me a small fortune for the syrup and the shipping. Please tell me I can use that because I now NEED your maple cream.
It depends on how dark it is Susan. “Grade B” which is the dark stuff normally meant for cooking apparently doesn’t always work. It doesn’t set properly or something. ~ karen!
The label says, “VT Grade A Dark Robust Taste.”
This is the first time I tried this type from Two Pigs Farm, and it definitely isn’t my favorite.
If you think it will work, I’ll give it a try and let you know how it turned out.
I will not mix it by hand because if it doesn’t turn out well I’ll be doubly bummed.
Keep your fingers crossed. I decided to spoil myself and bought 4 big bottles this year….don’t ya know!
I just checked my storage…I must have really felt the need to spoil myself. I’ve got 5 bottles of the stuff!
What else can it go on besides pancakes, waffles, sweet potatoes, chipped ice, or snow that is not yellow…and (I’m praying) turning into miraculously maple cream to die for!
Please point me in the right maple syrup direction, oh great and wonderous wizard of odd. ☺️💕
You’re just going to have to try Susan. It sounds like it might be too dark, but if you have 5 bottle then go ahead and sacrifice one! Especially if it isn’t your favourite. ~ karen!
Indigenous – cool that this is something learned from the original peoples of Canada.
That word caught my eye, too. I love it. I don’t think I’ve ever seen it on a recipe, before now. This sounds amazing, Karen. I would probably eat this on something stupid, like pancakes, because it has “butter” assumed in the title, or texture. It would be wasted on pancakes. It needs something more substantial, such as that Grilled Cheese sandwich. My friend ate her Sweet Potato Fries the other night with Maple Syrup. Maybe that would be good, also.
It would be delicious on sweet potato fries! A place near me serves theirs with a maple syrup/butter combo, and it’s divine!
My eyes have just rolled back into my head just thinking about that sandwich. It never pays to go to bed slightly hungry, then read Karen’s blog before shutting out the light. Now…I REALLY hungry, and I’m indeed in need of that Maple Cream Miracle. Thanks for sharing Karen!