How to Make Authentic Maple Syrup – By Tapping Maple Trees

Making maple syrup is an old timey, back to the land kind of fun. You only need a maple tree, a maple tap, a bucket for collecting sap and lots of time for boiling. The complete step by step guide on how to make maple syrup at home. (whether you live in a cabin in the woods, or a house in the suburbs)

Go grab your sap bucket, bonnet and lace up boots.  I’ll wait here in Vermont with the plough horse.  You don’t have a bonnet or lace up boots??  That’s O.K., because I don’t live in Vermont or have a plough horse. You don’t need any of those things to make maple syrup. 

All you need is ONE maple tree. It doesn’t even have to be yours. Tap a friend’s, family member’s or unsuspecting neighbour’s tree. I have yet to meet a single neighbour who won’t readily allow me to tap their tree in exchange for a bottle of golden maple syrup.

How is maple syrup made?

Syrup is made by boiling down sap. Sap is made of around 98% water and 2% sugars. The water is boiled away until the sugar content becomes 66%. So a LOT of water needs to boil off before it becomes syrup.

It takes 42 parts of sap to create 1 part syrup.

In order to do this you’re going to need a few things:

Tools needed.

Tapping

  1. Drill – The drill is for drilling a hole into your tree to insert the tap into.
  2. Drill Bit – This has to be the same size as your tap.
  3. Tap (spile) – This is what you tap into the tree for your sap to drip out of.
  4. Hook – The hook is on the tap and it allows you to hang your bucket off of it.
  5. Bucket – A bucket catches the sap. Duh.
  6. Bucket lid – You need this to keep debris from falling into your bucket of fresh, clear, beautiful sap.
 

Boiling & bottling

  1. Stock pot – A big stock pot with a lid to constantly heat up your sap.
  2. Shallow roasting pan –  It needs to be at least 5″ deep with a large surface area. This is known as your evaporation pan.
  3. A propane outdoor burner or fire pit / rocket stove.
  4. A digital or manual refractometer or a hydrometer or hydrotherm. (for testing syrup consistency)
  5. A digital thermometer
  6. Syrup filters
  7. Syrup bottles

Which variety of tree?

So what is the magical maple syrup tree?? It’s just a maple. Any maple.

Sugar maples are the most popular tree for making syrup because they have the highest sugar content in their sap but ANY maple will produce perfect maple syrup.

Maple sap has between 1-3% sugar in it (sucrose, fructose and glucose).

Don’t worry about whether your maple tree is the “right” kind of maple tree (Acer saccharum) for making syrup. 

They’re all the right kind.

Besides – sugar content varies based on the actual tree, its location and other factors. So you might have a black maple that actually has more sugar in its sap than your neighbour’s sugar maple.

The 4 varieties of Maple Trees that have the highest amount of sugar in their sap are sugar maples, black maples, red maples and silver maples.  

BUT WAIT!!  IT’S NOT FAIR! WHAT IF I DON’T HAVE ACCESS TO EVEN A SINGLE MAPLE TREE??!

O.K. Seriously, calm down. You’re being very dramatic. 

Don’t have access to a maple tree? You could make birch syrup instead. Yup. It’s made the exact same way as maple syrup only out of sap from a Birch tree.

You can also make walnut tree syrup!


What size of tree?

Do NOT tap a maple tree that is less than 10″ across.  (not around … across) Anything with a trunk that’s smaller than 10″ is too young and tapping it could kill it.

If your tree is 10 – 20″ – you can put 1 tap on it

If your tree is 20 – 27″ – you can put 2 taps on it

If your tree is 27+ (and healthy) – you can put 3 taps on it

(some say to never put more than 3 taps on a tree because it’s unhealthy for the tree and it changes the pressure in the tree too much so you don’t get as good a sap flow)


How to tap maple trees.

In the spring …

  1. Clean your sap buckets well with a light bleach solution before using them to prevent bacteria.
  2. Do not tap a tree that’s less than 10″ across.
  3. You can tap once nighttime temperatures are below freezing and daytime temperatures are above freezing.
  4. Drill a hole in your tree with a 7/16ths drill bit at a slightly upward angle.
  5. Insert the tap (spile) and hammer in gently.
  6. Hang bucket and collect sap.
  7. Store collected sap in a cool area for up to one week.

Tapping a maple tree for sap literally means putting a tap in it. How to tap a maple tree? You just bore a hole into the trunk, hammer in the tap and watch the sap flow out of it into your collection bucket.

The first time you do this it will be the most exciting thing you’ve ever experienced. Even if you’ve experienced the joy sounding really good singing once because you had a cold and sounded all sexy and husky.

Tips for tapping

  1. The hole you drill should be no more than 2″ deep. Mark your drill at 2″ using a piece of tape or a Sharpie.
  2. Drill your hole on a slightly upward angle.
  3. Choose a day that it’s above freezing to drill your hole.  If it’s freezing you risk the bark on your tree cracking which will cause sap to drip out.

Clear away the shavings from drilling with a small twig so your tap hole is clean.

Gently push your tap in.  Give it a small tap with a hammer. The tap needs to be tight enough in the tree that the weight of a full bucket doesn’t pull it out but not so tight it cracks the bark around it.

If it’s above freezing, the second you put your tap in it will start dripping.  And unless you have the shrivelled  heart of a rainbow hater, your eyes will drip too.

It’s a sappy miracle.

Don’t forget to put the lid on to keep twigs, bugs, leaves and curious teenage boys out of it.

Storing sap

Think of your sap as milk.  Not water.  Even though it is crystal clear like water.  It is perishable and needs to be kept cold. Store your daily collected sap in 5 gallon buckets with lids. You’ll have to empty out your sap pails once a day. You can keep the sap outside in the cold for up to 1 week.

If you have snow available, pile snow around the buckets to help them stay cold. Shady spots are the best.

Maple Water

“Maple water” is being sold and marketed as the new coconut water with all kinds of health benefits being claimed by sellers. They say this sap drink rehydrates humans better than regular water and contains vital nutrients. There is some truth – maple water does carry antioxidants and minerals that regular water doesn’t. But according to an actual scientific study on maple water it can’t rehydrate a person any better than regular water can.

When to tap.

You need to tap the maple tree when the “sap is flowing”. I’m sure you’ve heard that phrase before. So when does sap flow?

Sap flows in the early spring when nighttime temperatures are below freezing and daytime temperatures are above freezing.

A 7°C difference in the temperature range between night and day is ideal.  For you Americans, that’s a 12°F difference. For example:

For Canadians:

Nighttime temp    -2C

Daytime temp    7C

PERFECT FOR TAPPING A TREE!!

For Americans: 

Nighttime temp 28 F

Daytime temp 40 F 

Don’t worry too much about that.  Just remember as long as it’s spring and it’s below freezing at night and above freezing during the day the sap will be running. 

Fun fact: Sap doesn’t run because it melts inside the tree when it’s warmer out, it runs because of the change in atmospheric pressure. 

Making maple syrup.

Turning sap into syrup is just a matter of boiling away the water until you’re left with a high concentration of maple tasting syrup.

Quick Guide

STEP 1.  Heat your collected sap up in a stock pot with lid.  (It just heats faster if you have a pot w/ a lid)  Once hot, add it to the evaporation pan.

STEP 2.  Keep your evaporation pan of sap boiling.  When it starts to evaporate, add more hot sap from your stock pot.

STEP 3.  Once you’ve added all your sap to the evaporation pan and it’s looking a darker colour (like syrup) and is approximately 213 degrees, dump it all into a finishing pot.

STEP 4.  Water boils at 212 °F where I live.  Syrup always boils at 7.1°F (3.94°C)  above the boiling point of water. When you reach that temp., you have syrup.

STEP 5.  Now you need to test if what you have in the pot is no longer sap, but is actually syrup.  You can test whether it’s syrup in a few ways.

STEP 6.  Filter your syrup.

STEP 7.  To bottle your syrup to give away (as if) you need to reheat your syrup.

STEP 8.  Things are about to get real.  You can now, FILL YOUR BOTTLES.

Detailed Guide

STEP 1

Heating the sap takes many hours so it’s best to do it outside if you can. Otherwise you’ll have a kitchen with sticky walls. And floors. And cabinets. And cats.

Use a propane fuelled burner or a wood pit if you have one. You can also make a rocket stove like I show you here.

On boiling day ideally you have 2 areas going – one that’s heating a stock pot of sap, and another that’s boiling down the hot sap in an evaporation pan.

I’m just a gal making a few bottles of maple syrup in my backyard.

So I just skip the stock pot heating up phase, and add my cold sap straight into an evaporation pan.

An evaporation pan is any pan that is at least 5″ deep and has a large surface area. A large surface area means water can boil away faster.

Last season I built a maple syrup boiler out of cinderblock. It worked GREAT. If you have the room for this I recommend it 100%.

The base is 2 patio stones which are surrounded by 12 cinderblocks, with an additional 2 to act as doors.

1-2 evaporation pans can be placed on top.

The fire is built on the patio stones, underneath the evaporation pans.

STEP 2

Once the sap is hot, transfer enough to your evaporation pan to fill it. Let it boil. You’ll notice it become golden coloured as the water starts to evaporate.

As the sap boils down in the evaporation pan, continue to fill it with new, hot sap. Repeat this process until your reserve of fresh sap is gone and you only have the evaporation pan of sap left.

STEP 3

When the final sap in your pan reaches 213 degrees while boiling it’s time to pour it into a finishing pot and bring the operation inside. The last part of boiling down the syrup is more precise and using stove burners makes it easier.

The finishing pot is just any regular pot, but you need to use it.  It helps ensure you don’t burn your syrup, because the smaller pot (as opposed to the large surface area evaporation pan) means less chance of burning and ruining syrup.  Just trust me on this.

Transfer the pot to your stove and boil it until it’s syrup.

How to know when your sap is syrup

When it’s boiling temperature is 219°F.

Syrup always boils at 7.1°F (3.94°C)  above the boiling point of water. When you reach that temp., you have syrup.

Water boils at 212 °F.

So sap reaches 219°F while it’s boiling, it’s officially syrup.

To calculate your syrup boiling point, boil a pot of water and check the temperature. Add 7.1°F to that number and you will have the temperature you want your syrup to hit.

STEP 4

Once you *think* you have syrup, and its boiling point is at 219°F (depending where you live) it’s time to test it to confirm it.

Maple Syrup needs to be between 66.5% and 67.5% sugar.  Anything below or above that isn’t syrup.

You can test whether your sap has turned to syrup in a few ways:

The Drip Test

The first way is by looking at how it drips off of a spoon.

When it’s syrup, the final drop off of the spoon, will just hang there for quite some time.  When it finally drops off the spoon, you will see a *tiny* thread of a tail from the drop.  Like a sperm.  A maple syrup sperm drop.

This method is fine and it works but really to test maple syrup you should use scientific tools.

Using a hydrotherm or a refractometer.

A hydrotherm tests the viscosity of the syrup by floating in it. You have to have a vessel as deep as the hydrotherm, fill it with your syrup and put the tool in. You then read your viscosity level based on the level the hydrotherm floats at. They can be bought at maple syrup supply stores.

A refractometer is much easier to find and use. You have a choice between an inexpensive manual read refractometer like above, or a digital brix refractometer like below.

The manual is about $18. The digital around $140.

Both the manual and digital read the Brix level of liquids. In this case syrup. It will tell you exactly what the level of sugar in your syrup is down to a decimal point.

You just squeeze a drop of liquid onto the plate of the manual tool or into the recessed cup of the digital one. The refractometer does the rest.

If it reads between 66.5% and 67.5% you have syrup.

STEP 5

Filter your syrup. Large operations filter through a felt sock with paper liners inside of it. Filtering helps get rid of any contaminants as well as “sugar sand”. I ONLY USE PAPER LINERS. The felt sock absorbs a lot of syrup. More than I care to share with a bag of felt.

Sugar Sand: This is also known as Nitre. Sugar sand becomes visible when your sap becomes condensed as syrup. It’s a sandy looking sediment that’s made up of minerals from the earth in the tree’s sap. It isn’t bad for you but it’s gritty and will make your syrup cloudy.

If you don’t filter out sugar sand it will settle on the bottom of the maple syrup bottle. Just don’t shake up the bottle and it’ll stay at the bottom of the bottle and out of your tasty syrup.

STEP 6

After filtering you need to reheat the syrup before bottling to get rid of any “ick” that developed while you screwed around testing its Brix levels.

Reheat your syrup to between 82℃ – 88℃ (170℉ 190℉) before bottling.

You can skip the reheating step if you store your bottles of maple syrup in the freezer instead of in a cupboard.

Maple Syrup Grades

There used to be a confusing system of maple syrup grades and up until a few years ago the US and Canada had different names for them which made it even more confusing.

NOW all maple syrup is graded using these words which describe their colour.

Golden – delicate taste

Amber – rich taste

Dark – robust taste

Very Dark – strong taste

The grades or colour of maple syrup has nothing to do with how much the syrup is boiled. The colour of maple syrup depends on the daytime temperature the sap was collected

Maple syrup grades are explained a bit more along with the more sciencey stuff in my Maple Syrup Grading post.

I think you have all the information you need now. These are alllllll the things I struggled with or had questions about when I first had the inclination to tap my own tree for homemade maple syrup a decade ago.

Here’s some extra info that should clear up any other questions running through your head right now.

Maple Syrup by the Numbers

(numbers vary depending on the weather)

  1. It takes 10 gallons of sap to make 4 cups of Maple Syrup.
  2. It takes 1 week to collect 10 gallons of sap from a single large maple tree.
  3. That means you can produce 4 cups per week, for around 3 weeks, resulting in 12 bottles of syrup a year from one tree. (if that tree is producing very well)
  4. On a cold day it takes 9 hours to evaporate 10 gallons of sap outside.
  5. Then it takes another  1-2 hours inside on the stove to turn it into syrup.
  6. A minimum of 3 fingers are chopped off anyone who tries to steal a bottle of my syrup.

FAQ

Does Maple Syrup Go Bad?

There’s some debate about this and not a lot of scientific papers I can reference. A lot of maple syrup producing sites say that the mold found on the surface of maple syrup is harmless. They recommend scooping off the mold and then heating the syrup to 179℉ to kill remaining bacteria.

In this post from the Cornell University mushroom blog, the author recommends throwing away any moldy maple syrup even though the xerophile fungus (Wallemia sebi) isn’t always toxic.

How long does maple syrup last?

If it’s been properly bottled, maple syrup will last indefinitely on the shelf. Once opened it can be refrigerated for months. Freezing maple syrup in bottles is also a good way to store it.

What should sap look like?

Sap is clear liquid.  But near the end of the tapping season it may start to look slightly cloudy.  As long as it tastes fine and isn’t deeply cloudy it’s still good to use.

When can I tap a tree?

The perfect conditions for tapping a tree are when it’s below freezing at night and above freezing during the day. Once the tree starts to go into bud you can’t tap your trees anymore, the syrup this late sap makes will be bitter.

How long does sap run for?

It depends on the season, but generally you have 3-4 weeks before conditions aren’t right for sap to run anymore. Plus after 3-4 weeks the hole you drilled into the tree will start to scab up and close over.


The rate at which the sap drips will depend on the weather conditions that day. Sunny and warm always = faster running sap.

What IS sap?

Good question. Sap is basically the tree’s blood delivering minerals and nutrients around the tree. In the spring sap jumps into action pumping energy around the tree as buds are forming.

Maple Syrup Recipes

  1. Maple Cream
  2. Maple Bourbon BBQ Sauce
  3. Maple Whipped Cream

If you have even one INKLING of interest in making your own maple syrup DO IT.  Do it right now before you forget about it and the season has passed.  There are only 3 weeks every year that you can do this.

For the love of pancakes and french toast, do it this year.

How to Make Authentic Maple Syrup - By Tapping Maple Trees

141 Comments

  1. Bradley Dupre says:

    When I filter the sap there is a white powdery deposit on the filter paper. What is the composition of this substance?

  2. G goff says:

    Great information. Thanks. Last year we had cloudy maple syrup that went bad if it wasn’t stored in the fridge. I figure we didn’t finish it properly. Any recommendations?
    Thanks

    • Karen says:

      Hi Gillian. It sounds like you didn’t bottle it when it was at temperature. If you let the syrup cool before you bottle it you can run into mould. Cloudy syrup is usually from not filtering it so sugar sand remains suspended in it. ~ karen!

  3. Joy says:

    I don’t have any maple trees but I have lots of black walnut trees here in Missouri so I tapped a bunch this year. Just finished boiling down about 15 gallons of sap and the syrup is delicious! Thanks for your handy re-post, I’ve been wanting to try making syrup for years, and you always have the best tutorials!

  4. Gayle M says:

    I so wanted to try this when I saw your post a few years ago. I figured I could get my husband to do it with me (ha! He’s outside, I finish it off inside). He loves maple syrup so much he looks forward to it. We tap our 5 maples (one per 40 yr old tree) using food grade plastic taps and hoses we insert through holes drilled into the caps of (recycled) 2 liter vinegar jugs. Keeps the sap really clean. We get about 7 pints or so a year–enough to get him through to another season. Thanks, Karen!

  5. Mary W says:

    Comprehensive information! I wish I could visit during sap rising time as I’ve seen videos that show frozen dirt but can only laugh at the thought of dirt – freezing. Here in FL we have sand but of course no freezing sand so, no sap rising time. Envy rises, but only until I think of how cold it must be to freeze dirt. Then I’m happy with cane syrup or honey, instead. Actually I just use my unset jelly for waffles, oatmeal, etc. I have plenty of that. I missed the BINGO – just forgot. I’m very sorry but I know you guys must have had a good time.

  6. Randy P says:

    Thanks for the post – it does give one a greater appreciation for just how labor and energy intensive making “the real deal” is for a supplier., and why the cost is what it is. But you can’t beat the taste of honest maple syrup. good stuff.

  7. Tom says:

    I am glad you take off using the drip method. A heads up if you use a small stainless pot there is more surface area than a spoon. We used a spoon one year and kept trying to get it right. A neighbor came in and said get a small pot. He saw the drip immediately said get it off now. That was as excited as I ever saw him. Glad you are enjoying yourself.

  8. Angela says:

    Inspired us to get ready to try this at our rural forested property in CANADA!

  9. Dave Cross says:

    Thank you so much for doing the tough legwork, then sharing your results and how-to! I have tapped my trees for years and given the sap away to a friend with a sugar shack…in exchange for a couple of quarts…until they stopped two years ago. Now I’m trying my own small batch this year, with one tap on a large diameter sugar maple high sap producer. One tap, one day, 7 gallons. Second container is filling now!

    • Karen says:

      7 gallons in one day??! Holy crowwwww. ~ karen!

      • Dave Cross says:

        How about 15 gallons (56 liters?) in three days, from one tap on one wonderful tree! It needed a name, so after a day of ruminating, I’ve decided to name it Fuller. It doesn’t have a gender assigned, but I think it sounds male. I boiled to about 1.5 liters of syrup, now in jars, hopefully thick enough, soon to tell. With this seclusion thing going on, I am going to continue the boil all week, and maybe tap another tree or two…thank you for your jump start…

  10. Tiffany B. says:

    Any suggestions for if you had a margarita while boiling and weren’t paying enough attention and accidentally boiled your sap a little too long? Adding water is a bad idea…right? Instructions for maple candy?

    • Karen says:

      Yes! You can thin it (as long as you haven’t burned it) with water. Or even better – sap! Just remember you have to bring it back to a boil once you add the water. ~ karen!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The Art of Doing Stuff